CONDUCTING
A TWENTY-MINUTE INTERVIEW
With
its increased mobility, constant competition for top players and
instant dissemination of openings throughout the world, the current
job market breeds an increasingly savvy crop of applicants. What's
more, motivated job seekers can draw from innumerable seminars,
courses arid books to hone their interviewing skills. The interviewer,
on the other hand, probably holds as few interviews as possible
to keep his or her staff up to strength.
When
a candidates interviewing skills collide with the Interviewers urgent
need to hire, he or she may be talked into making a regrettable
decision. In the name of caution, the interviewer holds endless
rounds of one-to-three hour interviews, and his or her work suffers.
Both
pitfalls are avoidable. By taking a few common-sense measures, you'll
spend less time interviewing than you do today. At the same time,
you'll maintain control of your interviews, learn more and increase
your ability to make the best hiring decisions.
The
interview-for-hire process involves eight basic steps. Master them
and you'll improve your decisions and free up your calendar.
a.
Define the job before filling it.
Obviously,
clarify the job to be filled before filling it. Too often that process
is done in reverse. Don't make this mistake or you might hire a
perfect candidate for a job that doesn't exist.
When
creating a job description. Solicit the input of current employees
in similar positions. They know what the real job entails. Using
these employees as guides set realistic standards and qualifications.
An exceptional candidate won't be attracted unless exceptional compensation
and opportunity is offered.
Be
sure your hiring standards relate to job performance. Legally, you
must be prepared to demonstrate that all standards relate to reasonable
performance of the job and that they don't discriminate against
any group based on age, race, gender, religion, national origin,
marital status or physical handicap. The Equal Employment Opportunity
Commission enforces this stipulation and provides guidelines.
Include
all pertinent details in the description, such as benefits (and
short -comings) of the job, career potential, working environment
and special responsibility and demands. Before seeing candidates,
those involved in the hiring process should sign off on the filial
job description. Refine arid revise the description until their
clearance is given.
The
resulting document keeps everyone on the same wavelength. It's also
a helpful tool to use during the interview.
b.
Qualify (and cull) your candidates.
When
first starting in this career, you probably were advised to interview
for new jobs occasionally, regardless of your interest or qualifications
in the job. Keep in mind that some of your candidates may be following
the same advice.
To
save time, screen all candidates before meeting them. Study their
resumes. Ask them to fill out an application form. Check their references.
Then disqualify anyone who's unfit for the job. If the facts check
out, telephone the candidate before the actual in-person interview.
Before meeting the candidate, make sure he or she is serious about
job change.
c.
Organize and prepare.
Like
any meeting, a clear agenda for the interview increases your efficiency
and effectiveness. Because only twenty minutes are being allocated
to the process, every minute counts.
The
heart of each interview is your question period. Write out specific
questions based on the research acquired in Step 2. Type them for
easy reference.
Assume
the candidate will be prepared for the interview. The interviewer
should have a job description, questions and a notepad within easy
reach. In addition have a company information kit available for
the candidate.
If
the candidate must relocate, the information kit should profile
the company's area and region. Include information of interest to
every member of the family. Typically, applicants want to know about
schools, hospitals, medical care, places of worship and social,
cultural and recreational opportunities. The local chamber of commerce
usually can provide such literature and information.
d.
Set a friendly tone - two minutes.
Despite
a need to be brief, don't be curt or the interviewee will he uncomfortable
and uncommunicative. Set the subject at case. Choose a comfortable,
quiet setting for the interview and make sure he or she won't be
facing bright lights or the direct sun. Keep the applicant out of
an air conditioning draft. And make sure the chair isn't too low
or too high. To minimize distractions, ask your secretary to hold
all calls and interruptions.
When
the applicant first arrives, greet bin or her with a smile, warmth
and enthusiasm. Small talk helps break the ice. Offer a sincere
compliment about a strong point on the resumes or a favorable remark
made by a reference. Because only the strongest candidates are being
met, this should be accomplished easily. (This is one benefit of
performing Step 2.)
e.
Establish control of the meeting - two minutes.
Because
you initiated the meeting, you're expected to chair it. The first
step is to lead smoothly from Small talk into the interview. Give
a summary of what's to he accomplished today.
Briefly
describe your role in the company as well as the position (by title
only) for which the candidate is being interviewed. One possible
conversation is:
"We
have a unique and attractive opportunity for the right individual.
I'd like to spend the first part of our meeting discussing your
background and I'll share some information about the position with
you and then give you a chance to ask questions. This is just an
initial meeting for us to get acquainted, and it should take about
twenty minutes or so."
You've
kept your options open. Now, either the interview can be extended
as necessary or your schedule can be adhered to without making the
candidate feel cut short.
The
reason the candidate is questioned before being offered a description
of the position is elementary. Most candidates win slant their responses
to make themselves appear ideally suited. You need unbiased information,
however, and you want the applicant to understand that you're in
control.
f.
Ask questions - ten minutes.
Before
the appointment for the interview was made, the candidate's qualifications
were determined. Now, explore whether he or she is right for the
job. Evaluate style, chemistry and attitude. Express any concerns
that arose when reading the candidate's resume and talking with
references.
Although
this is the longest segment of the interview, ten minutes will he
adequate only if the questions are concise and you encourage equally
concise answers.
The
interviewer's questions should cover two areas in particular: the
candidate's experience and his or her personal qualities. Seek whatever
additional information that's necessary about the candidate's background,
skills, education, credentials and accomplishments as well as job
performance strengths and weaknesses. Ask about the candidate's
interests, ambitions, attitudes and personal style.
The
following sample questions will prepare you for the interview process:
- Please describe
your present job responsibilities. Which are most difficult and
why? Which are the most enjoyable?
- What accomplishment
in your present job are you most proud of? What was your best
idea (regardless of implementation)?
- What would
you like to have accomplished, hut haven't, in your present job?
What prevented you from doing so?
- What particular
strengths and weaknesses would you bring to this position?
- What do you
know about our company and this position?
- What would
it take to succeed in this position?
- What elements
are important to your job satisfaction and that of your subordinates?
- Describe
what qualities would make an ideal boss for this position?
- What are
your short and long term career objectives?
- What are
the biggest frustrations in your career?
- What might
your present company and department do to become more successful?
- What are
your hobbies and interests? Are they useful to your career or
in balancing the rest of your life?
- How would
you describe your personality? How would your associates describe
you?
- How do your
spouse and children feel about this possible change'?
- Why should
we hire you?
Avoid
questions that may be discriminatory. For example, acquaint yourself
with the candidate as a person, but don't ask about religious beliefs
or sexual preferences.
g.
Sell the opportunity- three minutes.
In
this step, entice the superior candidate to want the job. Begin
by telling the candidate how you feel about the job. "We feel
we have an outstanding opportunity and I'm excited about it. Whoever
assumes this responsibility will be important to our overall success.
That's why we're determined to hire the right candidate. "
Describe
the job opportunity in general terms. Again, avoid biasing the candidate's
answers in subsequent interviews. Therefore share general information
regarding responsibilities, reporting relationships, job benefits
and shortcomings. Don't, however, tell the candidate what you like
or dislike about his or her background relative to the job in question.
Don't reveal that his or her boss-to-be is looking for a golf partner
or distrusts people who wear bow ties.
It's
wise to 'work from the written job description during this phase
of the interview. Although you'll choose what to reveal in each
case, you'll also want all the facts at your disposal.
This
is a good time to summarize the history and growth of the company.
State the firm's reputation, market position and organizational
structure as it relates to the candidate's prospective job.
Don't
oversell or exaggerate the opportunity. False expectations are a
major cause of employee turnover. As any salesperson will tell you,
overselling often kills a deal that otherwise would have worked.
It's better to underplay the opportunity during this first meeting.
That
statement doesn't contradict the advice about showing enthusiasm
about the position. Be enthusiastic, but reserve some details of
the job to elicit the candidate's further interest and excitement
in subsequent Interviews.
h.
Answers questions and close -- three minutes.
In
this final step, the candidate has the opportunity to ask questions
about the prospective job. An aggressive candidate will try to assume
control throughout the interview, so don't allow that to happen.
Reduce the candidate's questions to a minimum by saving them for
the end. Furthermore, many questions will have been answered during
the flow of the interview.
Once
the question period begins, however, let the candidate know that
this is his or her opportunity. By now, you have a good sense as
to whether the candidate should he invited back for subsequent interviews.
Accordingly, you can expand the interview or keep it brief at this
time. If the candidate asks sensitive questions or makes inquiries
about matters you don't want to discuss yet, such as compensation
or hiring dates, explain that these subjects will be covered during
subsequent interviews.
Expect
candidates to ask some of the following questions before accepting
a position with your firm:
- What are
the responsibilities of this position, and which are the most
important?
- What results
are expected of this position?
- What are
the limits of my responsibility and authority?
- What problems
and opportunities are associated with this position?
- In your opinion,
what specific aspects of my background make me right or wrong
for this position?
- What support
is available to help me fulfill my charge here?
- Will I have
subordinates? What are their strengths and weaknesses?
- Who will
be my superior and what are his or her strengths and weaknesses?
- Are there
any projects in motion for which I will inherit responsibility?
What is their history and status?
- What are
the goals of this company and my department?
- What criteria
will he used to evaluate my performance? When are evaluations
scheduled?
- What can
you tell me about my peers in this company?
- Why did my
predecessor leave this position?
- Why did you
come to work here, and why do you stay?
- What advancement
can a person expect - in this company and in the industry at large
- after doing this job well?
Indicate
the conclusion of the interview with body language (e.g., glance
at your watch or calendar) and by summarizing your remarks.
Close
all interviews on a positive note. Thank the candidate for his or
her time and interest, and let him or her know what to expect next.
Say, for example, will be interviewing in this first round for the
next two weeks. "We'll let you know by the end of next week
as to whether and when we might meet again." If he or she is
a prime candidate for hire, say a few words of encouragement. Let
him or her know you feel good about the meeting and you look forward
to the next meeting.
The
benefits of a well-prepared twenty-minute interview are clear. Following
this approach, you'll accomplish your purpose quickly. In less than
half an hour you'll gain insight into each pre qualified candidate
while selling the opportunity so it encourages the prime candidates.
There
are also other benefits of the short interview. The candidates who
are invited back will be flattered that it took only twenty minutes
for the interviewers to see this possible value to the organization.
At the same time, applicants who aren't asked back find the bad
news easier to swallow. After all, they weren't required to sit
through marathon interviews just to be rejected.
Of
course, the short initial interview necessitates one or wore additional
interviews before hiring. This, too, is an advantage. Most candidates
prefer to be courted and given consideration by several parties
before a decision is made. In addition, interviewers also need some
time to reflect on the candidate and his or her suitability for
the job.
Summarize
your notes immediate after the meeting while the details and nuances
are fresh in your mind. Then file them in a safe place. In the future,
these observations may be critical reminders of the candidate's
visit.
In
analyzing and grading the candidate be aware of your personal biases.
Don't allow a candidate's isolated response or question to outweigh
an otherwise attractive set of qualifications and qualities.
Always
send interviewees a letter of thanks, even if it's to announce that
they are no longer under consideration for the position.
Finally, involve others in the hiring decision. Make sure they meet
the outstanding candidates. Because their futures will be affected
along with your own, ask for their opinions. Seek consensus, but
don't let one cynic, bigot or misanthrope hold the job hostage.
A
final word of caution: Check references thoroughly before the final
offer is made. You want to hire the candidate who is as he or she
truly is, not how he or she appears.
The previous information is written and copyrighted by Frederick C. Hornberger, Jr., president of Hornberger Management Company, a national board and executive search firm specializing in the construction industry. This information is provided for personal use only. It may not be copied, printed or distributed to anyone other than you the reader, for any reason without permission from the author. Contact the author at address One Commerce Center, #747, Wilmington, Delaware 19801, phone 302-573-2541, email [email protected], or through the company web site at www.hmc.com.
|